Published tribunal order
Tenancy Tribunal case 5350121 — Exemplary damages at 22 Riverview Street, Putaruru, Putaruru 3411
Decided 23 Oct 2026 · Published 23 Oct 2026 · Application 5350121
- Exemplary damages
- Leaks
- State of repair
Order
- [The tenant/s] tenant/s] landlord/s] and [The tenant/s] tenant/s] landlord/s] are to pay [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] $775.00 in compensation immediately, calculated as follows: Brief description of damageAmount Loss of amenity – water ingress$325.00 Loss of amenity – front entrance $300.00 Total compensation$625.00 Exemplary damages – failure to maintain$150.00 Total including exemplary damages$775.00
Reasons
- The tenancy commenced on 13 October 2017 and ended on 17 October 2025.
- On 3 August 2026, the Tribunal dismissed the tenant’s claim concerning leaks.
- By order dated 28 September 2026, a rehearing was granted limited to the leaks and front-door lock.
- The tenant has provided screenshots of additional video evidence with date information. The video evidence was not available to view at the hearing. Did the landlords fail to maintain the premises in a reasonable state of repair by not adequately addressing recurring leaks, contrary to s 45(1)(b), and what remedy, if any, is appropriate?
- Section 45(1)(b) requires landlords to provide and maintain premises in a reasonable state of repair, having regard to their age and character.
- Section 40(1)(d) requires tenants to notify landlords as soon as possible after discovering damage or a need for repairs. Notification need not be written.
- In Barfoot & Thompson Ltd v Casey, 1 the District Court confirmed that s 45 imposes a positive maintenance obligation. Liability does not depend exclusively on express notification by a tenant. Landlords may be expected to identify defects reasonably apparent upon inspection, although the obligation does not impose absolute liability for latent and undiscoverable defects.
- Under s 78(1)(d), the Tribunal may award compensation for proven loss, including diminished satisfaction or utility of the premises.
- In Casey the District Court approved assessment by reference to rent and the nature, extent and duration of the fault. 2
- Exemplary damages are separately governed by s 109, which requires intentional commission of an unlawful act and consideration of the effect on the person who suffered the act, as well as the public interest. Application
- The landlords acknowledge earlier leaks and provided evidence of roof repairs undertaken in 2019. Gutters were cleared and additional flashings installed. They understood those repairs to have resolved the problem.
- The tenant had produced screenshots of videos of the alleged water ingress. The Tribunal is unable to view videos on a party’s phone. The videos appear to show water ingress issues on 13 October 2024, 11 February 2025 and 19 April 2025. The screenshots show water externally spilling down from the soffits and, in one screenshot, water is seen spilling through the ceiling, through a join, and inside the conservatory. There are some signs that water has made it inside the home as I could see a potion of the ceiling with cracks, mould and discolouration (patches). This could also have been from a past leak. There is no clear 1 Barfoot & Thompson Ltd v Casey (DC Auckland, CIV-2005-004-001762, 7 November 2007) at [28]– [36] and [45]–[50]. 2 Ibid. at [74]–[79]. evidence of leaks inside the home itself. I accept leaks recurred after the earlier repairs in 2019, but it appears to me that the gutters may not have been cleaned or have become obstructed, leading to water overflowing into the roof. The tenant’s evidence does not establish when the landlords became aware of the water ingress, or whether they subsequently failed to respond reasonably.
- The tenant alleges that the Landlords (Hannah) was notified verbally on 14 October 2024 and on subsequent occasions, including during school drop-offs and inspections. I have considered those claims. No contemporaneous communications establish when those particular reports were made, their substance or the landlords’ response.
- The historical text/messenger messages referred to by the tenant have still not been recovered.
- The landlords were responsive. In 2019 when leaks were discovered, they hired contractors to repoint and fix aspects of the roof.
- I have also considered whether the landlords ought reasonably to have identified the recurrence independently. The evidence includes deterioration of carpet and ceiling surfaces. An inspection was arranged for 10 April 2025, and further footage of deterioration was recorded on 11 April 2025. Those circumstances are relevant to what may reasonably have been observable. The tenant says the landlords gave her a rug to go over the discoloured carpet, but there is no evidence of a leak being discussed or the tenant going back to the landlords to say this was an inadequate solution.
- There is insufficient evidence establishing that signs of continuing water ingress, rather than earlier deterioration, were sufficiently apparent during inspections to require further investigation. The landlords’ evidence is that they did not observe subsequent leaks and believed their earlier repairs had been effective.
- I accept that the landlords’ obligation was not dependent on receiving written notification. Nevertheless, considering the previous remedial work, the intermittent nature of the recorded leaks, the competing accounts of notification and the evidence of inspections, I am not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the landlords knew, or ought reasonably to have known, of the recurrence and subsequently failed to take reasonable steps to address it.
- Nevertheless, I am satisfied that there was moisture ingress and the tenant should be compensated for the loss of satisfaction, utility or amenity that resulted from these defects.
- The evidence establishes that the landlords took approximately three months to complete reasonable repairs after becoming aware of the recurring leaks, and that the delay was unreasonable.
- I award $325 compensation, being 13 weeks at $25 per week. Did the landlords fail to provide and maintain reasonably secure locking arrangements under s 46(1), or fail to maintain the front-door lock in a reasonable state of repair under s 45(1)(b), and what remedy, if any, is appropriate?
- Section 46(1) requires landlords to provide and maintain locks and similar devices necessary to ensure that premises are reasonably secure.
- Section 45(1)(b) separately requires landlords to maintain premises in a reasonable state of repair. A locking arrangement may therefore provide reasonable security while still falling short of the landlord’s maintenance obligations.
- Section 78(1)(d) permits compensation for proven diminished amenity. As recognised in Casey, 3 an assessment may be made by reference to the rental value of the premises, the extent of the impairment and its duration. Exemplary damages under s 109 are separate and require consideration of intentionality and the statutory factors.
- The original handle lock was defective. The landlords installed an internal deadbolt, which enabled the front door to be secured but prevented it from being unlocked externally. The tenant consequently used the rear entrance, which had external lighting.
- The additional video evidence, screenshot dated 9 June 2022, supports the duration of this solution. The Tenant has not established the premises remained insecure after installation of the deadbolt. Nor has the tenant produced contemporaneous correspondence requesting restoration of external operation after the deadbolt was fitted. I nevertheless accept her evidence that using the rear entrance was inconvenient and that she felt unsafe doing so at night.
- I find that the deadbolt provided reasonable security for the purposes of s 46(1). However, securing the front door without restoring its ordinary external operation did not fully discharge the landlords' maintenance obligation under s 45(1)(b).
- The tenant consequently experienced diminished utility by being required to use the rear entrance. Although this arrangement continued for approximately three years, the remainder of the dwelling remained available for ordinary residential use. The impairment was therefore limited but persistent.
- Assessing the impairment against the rental value of the premises as a whole, I award $300 compensation for diminished amenity under s 78(1)(d).
- Exemplary damages are considered separately. The landlords knew the original external lock remained defective and deliberately retained the replacement arrangement without restoring its ordinary operation. Having regard to their intention, the limited consequences, the tenant's interests and the public interest 3 Ibid. under s 109(3), I consider the original $150 exemplary-damages award remains appropriate. The modest amount reflects the landlords' attempt to improve security and the limited nature of the resulting inconvenience.