Published tribunal order
Tenancy Tribunal case 5356725 — Tenancy dispute at Unit/Flat Flat 11, 259 The Terrace, Te Aro, Wellington 6011
Decided 21 Sept 2026 · Published 21 Sept 2026 · Application 5356725
Order
- [The tenant/s] tenant/s] and [The tenant/s] tenant/s] are to pay Oxygen.Co.Nz Limited $1,428.00 immediately, being $1,400 in compensation for loss of rent and the application filing fee of $28.00.
Reasons
- This is a rehearing of the landlord’s claim arising from the early termination of a fixed-term tenancy.
- The tenancy commenced on 13 May 2024 at rent of $700 per week and was due to expire on 12 May 2025.
- The Tribunal found that the tenants had repudiated the tenancy and terminated it on 2 April 2025. 1 The Tribunal found that the landlord was required to mitigate its loss from 19 February 2025, when the tenants returned the keys and unequivocally made clear that they had vacated. It found the landlord had taken reasonable steps to mitigate during the six weeks between 19 February and 2 April.
- The Tribunal expressly left open whether the landlord was entitled to compensation for loss of rent after 2 April because that depended upon what 1 [2025] NZTT 5159872, 5163592 subsequently occurred and whether the premises were re-let. That is the issue now before the Tribunal.
- The landlord seeks $4,000, representing $100 per day for the 40 days from 2 April until the fixed term would have expired on 12 May 2025. Has the landlord established a compensable loss resulting from the tenants’ repudiation after 2 April 2025 and, having regard particularly to mitigation, what amount of compensation is reasonable?
- Rent itself did not continue to accrue after the tenancy was terminated. Section 31(2) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1986 (RTA) provides for rent to be apportioned upon termination. The present claim is therefore properly considered as one for compensation rather than rent.
- Section 49 provides that, where a party breaches a tenancy agreement or the Act, the other party must take all reasonable steps to limit the damage or loss arising from the breach, in accordance with the ordinary law of mitigation.
- The obligation is one of reasonableness. A landlord is not required to guarantee that premises will immediately be re-let, nor to take every conceivable step. However, loss which could reasonably have been avoided is not properly recoverable from the party in breach.
- Section 78(1)(d) permits the Tribunal to order payment of money, and under s 85(2) the dispute is to be determined according to general legal principles and the substantial merits and justice of the case.
- The earlier Tribunal approached repudiation on the same basis. It held that compensation for post-termination loss may be available where repudiation is established, but that the landlord must take reasonable steps to mitigate that loss. Application
- There is no difficulty establishing an initial causal connection between the repudiation and some loss. Had the tenancy continued according to its terms, the tenants were contractually committed until 12 May 2025. No replacement tenant was paying rent during the remaining 40 days. The landlord therefore suffered an actual financial loss.
- That does not mean, however, that the entire $4,000 automatically follows from the repudiation. The issue is whether the landlord has established that the whole of that loss remained reasonably unavoidable after taking proper steps to re-let.
- The history before 2 April is relevant. In December 2024 the landlord already knew the tenants wanted to leave in late January. The landlord told them that its objective was to re-let the property as soon as possible.
- Significantly, the landlord also identified at that time an oversupply of rental accommodation and anticipated that the rent might have to be reduced gradually to attract a replacement tenant.
- The tenants did not simply leave without any attempt to assist. They proposed undertaking advertising themselves and in January provided the landlord with a link to their Facebook advertising. The Tenants’ have contemporaneous correspondence to suggest their Facebook advertising generated interest and viewings. I am satisfied there were prospective enquiries.
- There were also matters weighing against the tenants. They vacated without clearly confirming the precise date and ceased paying rent. They did not respond to the Landlord’s requests for confirmation they had left, and on 10 February maintained to Tenancy Services that the premises had not been abandoned. They did not finally return the keys until 19 February. The earlier Tribunal reasonably regarded that date as the point from which the landlord was clearly able and required to undertake the re-letting process.
- By 2 April the property had therefore been available to the landlord for re-letting for approximately six weeks. The earlier Tribunal found that six weeks was not an unreasonable period in the circumstances and that the landlord had reasonably mitigated its loss up to that date. I accept that finding as the factual starting point for the period now in issue.
- The evidence concerning what happened after 2 April is considerably less detailed. Ms Ricketts said that the landlord continued to advertise the premises, conducted “several” viewings and reduced the rent several times. The landlord produced a Renti Listing Summary showing 17 enquiries, 49 viewings created, 13 registered viewers, 11 completed viewings and 851 TradeMe views. The problem is that the report aggregates activity from 31 January 2025 to 19 March 2026. I cannot see how many enquiries or viewings occurred during the relevant 2 April– 12 May 2025 period, nor can I see the dates or amounts of the rent reductions or the identities or circumstances of interested applicants. I have no information regarding why particular applicants did not proceed.
- Ms Ricketts said the property was ultimately not re-tenanted until August. I accept that the landlord did not simply withdraw the property from the market and allow the loss to accumulate.
- However, those general statements do not permit close examination of the reasonableness of the re-letting process. There was no detailed evidence before me identifying any of the following: a. the advertisements in place between 2 April and 12 May; b. the platforms used; c. dates for which the rent was reduced; d. the rent sought at particular times; e. the number of enquiries or applications received; or f. the reasons individual applicants did not proceed.
- The terms upon which the premises were being offered are also unclear.
- When asked whether the property was being offered on a fixed-term or periodic basis, Ms Ricketts thought both were available but could not confirm that. Her evidence was that the usual approach was to leave the position open while saying that 12 months was preferred. In a difficult rental market, whether a landlord was insisting upon or strongly preferring another lengthy fixed term could materially affect the pool of available tenants, and this is a highly relevant piece of information not presently before the Tribunal.
- This absence of detail matters because the landlord itself knew before the tenants vacated that the market was oversupplied and that $700 might be above what prospective tenants would pay. The difficulty in re-letting was therefore not solely a consequence of the tenants’ conduct. Market demand and the price at which the property was offered were highly relevant intervening considerations, which, in my view, constitute part of an evolving set of circumstances in this case.
- The tenants gave evidence at the rehearing that several people who approached them were interested in the premises but wanted the rent reduced, and that the landlord did not accept those proposals. I treat that evidence cautiously. There is no direct evidence from those prospective tenants and no material showing whether they were otherwise suitable applicants or what rent they were actually prepared to pay.
- I therefore do not find that the landlord unreasonably rejected any particular tenant. But the evidence cannot simply be ignored either. It is consistent with the landlord’s own December assessment that demand at $700 was weak and with Ms Ricketts’ evidence that the landlord subsequently reduced the rent several times.
- The tenants’ written material also records that the property was eventually re-let at $645 per week. This accords with the uncontested evidence that repeated rent reductions eventually occurred.
- The tenants also rely on the condition of the property. I am not satisfied, however, that the evidence establishes that those defects caused the tenants to vacate the premises. I give that matter limited weight in assessing the landlord’s present claim.
- I have also considered the tenants’ evidence concerning their financial circumstances and the employment difficulties that led them to leave. Those matters explain the background to the repudiation, but they do not determine whether the landlord subsequently suffered compensable loss.
- There is insufficient independent evidence to make findings about the wider Wellington employment market. The more reliable market evidence for present purposes is the landlord’s own contemporaneous acknowledgement of an oversupply of rental accommodation.
- I am therefore satisfied of two things. First, the landlord genuinely continued to suffer loss after 2 April and continued making efforts to re-let. It would be artificial to say that all causal connection with the tenants’ repudiation disappeared the moment the termination order was made.
- Secondly, I am not satisfied that the landlord has proved that all 40 days of the subsequent vacancy were reasonably unavoidable. By 2 April the property had already been available for re-letting for six weeks. The landlord knew it was operating in an oversupplied market and knew a rent reduction might be necessary. Against that background, evidence of “several” viewings and “several” rent reductions, without dates, prices, advertisements or applicant records, is insufficient to establish that the full continuing loss should be transferred to the tenants.
- This is particularly so where Oxygen is a professional property manager. Records of advertising, applications, viewing activity and changes to the asking rent are the type of evidence that could reasonably have demonstrated what occurred. Their absence does not prove that the landlord acted unreasonably, but it limits the extent to which the Tribunal can be satisfied that the claimed loss was unavoidable.
- Conversely, I do not accept the tenants’ submission that compensation should be refused altogether. The landlord had already reasonably marketed an empty property for six weeks before 2 April, continued conducting viewings afterwards and did in fact reduce the rent. The fact that the property ultimately remained vacant well beyond 12 May provides some support for the landlord’s evidence that the property was genuinely difficult to let.
- The appropriate result therefore lies between the two positions. The landlord has established some continuing compensable loss, but not the whole $4,000.
- It is not possible on the evidence to identify a precise day upon which loss ceased to be reasonably attributable to the repudiation. The Tribunal must therefore make an evaluative assessment of the recoverable loss. In doing so, I take into account the following: a. The six weeks of reasonable mitigation already recognised by the earlier Tribunal; b. the continued but incompletely documented/evidenced re-letting efforts; c. the known oversupply of rentals; d. the need for rent reductions; e. the uncertainty concerning prospective applicants and the terms being offered; and f. the fact that the property was ultimately not re-let until August.
- Doing the best I can on that evidence, I consider compensation equivalent to a further two weeks’ rent to be fair and reasonably attributable to the tenants’ repudiation. At $700 per week that is $1,400.00.
- This follows and assessment of the proven loss in the particular circumstances of this case, having regard to the evidential uncertainty surrounding mitigation after 2 April.
- As the landlord has been partly successful, I also order reimbursement of the $28 filing fee.