Tenantcheck Insights · Case study
Tenancy Tribunal case 5425804 — Rent arrears
Decided 18 Sept 2026 · Published 18 Sept 2026 · Application 5425804
- Rent arrears
At a glance
Key facts from the published tribunal order.
Adjudicator
R Kee
Claims & awards
What this tenancy cost at tribunal — claim, category, amount, and party awarded, with reconciled net total.
No individual claim amounts were reconciled for this order. View the official Ministry of Justice PDF for full detail.
Order
- The parties’ names and identifying details including the tenancy address must not be published.
- The application for rehearing is dismissed.
- The interlocutory stay is cancelled.
Reasons
- On 3 July 2026, the Tribunal issued a decision that among other things found that Mr [tenant’s surname] extended a fixed-term tenancy with the landlord or agreed to a new fixed-term tenancy with the landlord continuing until 15 July 2026. Based on that finding, the Tribunal found that the tenant owed the landlord $6,082.86 rent arrears.
- The tenants applied for a rehearing of the claim for the Tribunal’s decision due to a substantial wrong or miscarriage of justice.
- I heard the application for rehearing at North Shore District Court on 10 September 2026.
- All the parties appeared. Legal principles
- The Tribunal may order a rehearing where “a substantial wrong or miscarriage of justice has or may have occurred or is likely to occur”. 1
- Usually, the party applying for the rehearing must show that something went wrong with the Tribunal’s procedure, for example, that they did not receive notice of the hearing, or they were not able to properly present their case. A rehearing may also be granted where there is new evidence that was not reasonably available at the first hearing if it could have affected the outcome.
- Merely that the Tribunal was wrong in its findings of fact, or its application of the law is not sufficient of itself to establish a miscarriage of justice has occurred or may occur. A rehearing is not intended as an alternative to an appeal. It follows, the Tribunal must not grant a rehearing just because a party is unhappy with the decision, or to give them a second opportunity to present their case. In Wellington City Council v McMillan [2003] DCR 50, Judge Tuohy held that the statutory language set a high standard, and that the words of the section: [18] ...most obviously apply ... to cases of procedural error eg a hearing which takes place in the absence of a party who has not been given notice of it; the improper admission or rejection of evidence; misconduct by the adjudicator or by one of the parties or a witness. The words may also encompass the discovery of new and important evidence not previously available. [19] In my view, however, the words do not cover a complaint that the Tribunal was merely mistaken or wrong in its findings of fact or in its application of the law. There are two reasons for this. First the strength of the language in s 105 is such that something more than a mere wrong decision must be shown. The section does not speak of a decision being wrong, but of a substantial wrong or miscarriage of justice occurring. This implies obvious injustice, not merely an erroneous decision.
- Judge Christiansen in Loh v Puri [2019] NZDC 1993 observed: Rehearings are about challenges to processes and procedures and are not about what the adjudicator found or the decisions the adjudicator made. 1 Section 105(1) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1986 (RTA). Discussion
- The tenants submit that the Tribunal did not give the tenants a reasonable opportunity to be heard, especially by not giving Ms [tenant’s surname] adequate opportunity to address the Tribunal.
- The tenants submit in their written submissions: The central issue was whether the fixed-term tenancy was validly renewed or extended after 12 October 2025. The Tribunal found that the tenancy continued as a fixed-term tenancy until 13 February 2026, resulting in a substantial rent award against the tenants. The tenants say a rehearing is required for the following reasons. First, [tenant’s name] was a named tenant under the original tenancy agreement and a party directly affected by the Tribunal's order. She did not sign the alleged renewal document, did not see it before it was signed, was not present when it was signed, and did not consent to a further fixed-term tenancy. The Tribunal accepted that the extension did not include Olesya because she did not sign it, but still found that the tenancy continued as a fixed-term tenancy. This has resulted in a substantial financial obligation being imposed in circumstances where one of the named tenants never agreed to the alleged renewal. Secondly, Olesya was not given a proper opportunity to present her position at the hearing. English is not her first language, and she required a Russian interpreter. Without interpretation support, she was unable to properly explain that she did not see, understand, sign, or consent to the alleged renewal document. Her evidence was central to the issue of whether both tenants agreed to renew or extend the fixed-term tenancy. Thirdly, the tenants say the hearing process did not give them a fair opportunity to respond to the landlord's evidence and submissions. Important issues were discussed with the landlord and treated as already dealt with before the tenants were given a proper opportunity to respond. When the tenants attempted to address those matters, they were told that they had already been discussed. This affected their ability to present their case on the central issue.
- The tenants did not pursue the issue of not having a Russian interpreter. Both are fluent in English even though it is not their first language. Both tenants expressed themselves clearly. I am not aware that the tenants requested an interpreter for the earlier hearings. The Tribunal requested a Russian interpreter for the most recent hearing based on the rehearing application grounds. No Russian interpreter attended and the tenants did not raise that as an issue at the most recent hearing, so the hearing proceeded in the absence of an interpreter.
- The Tribunal found only one of the tenants was party to the new or extended fixed-term tenancy. The other tenant was not present at the time the relevant tenant signed the written agreement.
- That the Tribunal declined to hear further evidence and submissions on the issue does not mean it has not given the parties a reasonable opportunity to be heard. The Tribunal frequently directs parties to move on from a particular issue. It has a discretion to hear further evidence or submissions even after the issue has been discussed where the interests of justice require that. I am not satisfied that the Tribunal did not give the tenants a reasonable opportunity to be heard in this regard even though it declined to hear the tenant further on the issue.
- Nor do I accept that “Important issues were discussed with the landlord and treated as already dealt with before the tenants were given a proper opportunity to respond.”
- The tenants’ written submissions and their submissions at the hearing do not satisfy me that the Tribunal’s decision was arrived at in breach of the basic principle of natural justice that the parties are entitled to a reasonable opportunity to be heard or that the decision is affected by a substantial wrong or miscarriage of justice. Conclusion
- The tenants’ application for rehearing is dismissed.
- The stay is lifted.