Tenantcheck Insights · Case study
Tenancy Tribunal case 5562578 — Tenancy dispute
Decided 23 Oct 2026 · Published 23 Oct 2026 · Application 5562578
At a glance
Key facts from the published tribunal order.
Adjudicator
J Greene
Claims & awards
What this tenancy cost at tribunal — claim, category, amount, and party awarded, with reconciled net total.
No individual claim amounts were reconciled for this order. View the official Ministry of Justice PDF for full detail.
Order
- An application for suppression has been made in this case, and the Tribunal orders suppression of the landlord’s name and identifying details.
- The application is dismissed.
Reasons
- Both parties attended the hearing today.
- The tenant has applied for an order varying the tenancy agreement so that the landlord must renew the fixed term tenancy every year for 3 years at the same rent unless the owner sells the premises or wants them for their own use.
- In the alternative, the tenant seeks compensation of $5,766.00 to cover his relocation and insurance costs if he is required to move at the end of the current fixed term tenancy.
- The tenant also seeks the cost of parking he has paid from 14 May 2026 to date, and a rent reduction of about $221.00 per month to be renewed each year and increased (if the parking costs increase) to reflect his on-going costs. Background
- The tenant responded to an advertisement for these premises which stated they were available for a minimum fixed term of 12 months with a longer term available by negotiation.
- The tenant responded to the advertisement and said that off-street parking was a must. He also said that he wanted a long-term (3 year) tenancy.
- The tenant received automated responses to his enquiries from the landlord’s (the owner’s) agent.
- When the tenant received a response saying the place was available long-term, he completed his application.
- The tenant believed that he was applying for a unit with a carpark. At the viewing on 9 April, he was told there was no carpark and its inclusion in the listing was a mistake.
- There were further discussions about the term of the tenancy. The agent advised [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] that the owner would not agree to a 3-year term but would offer a 1-year term and would contact him after 9 months to see whether he wanted to renew. [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] signed the tenancy agreement believing that he could renew each year other than if the owner wanted to sell the premises or take them back for their own use.
- [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] considers that he was induced to enter the tenancy, and he considers that the terms of the tenancy were misrepresented. He states that he has since discovered that a landlord can decided not to renew the tenancy for any reason after 9 months have passed. Law
- The Tribunal may make an order varying or setting aside an agreement where it appears to the Tribunal that an agreement between the parties has been induced by fraud, misrepresentation, or mistake 1 .
- A fixed term tenancy becomes periodic unless notice is given by either party of their intention not to continue with the tenancy within the effective period – the period that starts on the 90 th day before the date on which the tenancy expires and end on the 21 st day before that date 2 . The parties can also agree to enter 1 See section 78(1)(g) Residential Tenancies Act 1986 (RTA) another fixed term tenancy or to simply vary the existing tenancy for a further period. Issues
- The Tribunal must determine these issues: •Was the tenant induced by a misrepresentation by the landlord? If so, should the Tribunal vary the tenancy agreement? •Should the Tribunal reimburse [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s]’s parking costs to date and reduce the rent to deduct his future parking costs? Discussion Was the tenant induced by a misrepresentation by the landlord? If so, should the Tribunal vary the agreement?
- The only advertisement produced in evidence was that produced by the landlord. The advertisement states: This home is available for a minimum fixed term tenancy of 12 months. A longer term may be available by negotiation.
- What happened after that amounted to negotiation around the term of the tenancy. But the landlord decided not to offer a longer fixed term. [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] was aware of that. He responded to the landlord on 14 April 2026: ...I talked to xx and she said xxx will contact me in 9 months to reassess lease and see if I want to renew. I told her I’m keen to take it on that basis...
- The reference to 9 months is a reference to section 60A(2A) RTA which defines the effective period.
- There was no misrepresentation either in the advertisement or in any later discussions. They were simply pre-contract discussions/negotiations. [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] was aware of the operation of section 60(2A) RTA because he refers to the start of the effective period in his message referred to above. He also stated in another message to the landlord that it had been explained to him that he could renew the tenancy each year ‘so long as the landlord is still letting it at the time of renewal’. That was a correct representation of the law. The landlord could choose to offer another fixed term tenancy or to vary the existing tenancy and extend the term (or not), if notice was given within the effective period. 2 See section 60A(2) and (2A) RTA
- [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] signed the tenancy agreement on 14 April 2026 and the term of the tenancy was clearly stated.
- Without a misrepresentation the Tribunal cannot (will not) vary the agreement. But even if there had been, [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s]’s expectation that the agreement would be varied for a 3-year term at the same rent is unrealistic. The evidence simply does not exist to record that as an agreed term.
- Finally, [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] has to an extent ‘jumped the gun’. Again, even it he had shown some kind of inducement (which he has not) nothing adverse has happened. The Tribunal does not generally make prospective orders; it is reactive. [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] seems to assume that his landlord will not renew the fixed term tenancy when there is no indication that is the case. It is possible that his tenancy will be renewed each year on the same, possibly even better terms. Who knows what might yet happen? Should the Tribunal reimburse [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s]’s parking costs to date and reduce the rent to deduct his future parking costs?
- [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] has no basis on which to claim the cost of parking from his landlord. The advertisement produced in evidence does not state that there is parking as part of the tenancy. Even if there had been another listing that mentioned parking, if that were a mistake, it was something that could be corrected. Only if the carpark were included in the tenancy agreement which [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] signed would he have a case to claim compensation in the form of parking costs.
- To the contrary, the tenancy agreement states at clause 58: No parking – The tenant acknowledges that the tenancy does not include any off- street car parking. The Tenant must not park, or allow guests to park, anywhere on the Property including any grass verge at the front of the Property.
- That was the agreement (the contract) [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s] signed. It could not be clearer.
- There is no legal basis on which the Tribunal could require the landlord to reimburse (or deduct from rent) [The tenant/s] tenant/s] tenant/s]’s car parking costs. Result
- The application is dismissed. Name suppression
- Both parties sought name suppression. The landlord is entitled to name suppression as its defence to the application is fully successful. The tenant is not entitled to name suppression as the application is unsuccessful 3 .