Tenantcheck Insights · Case study
Tenancy Tribunal case 5582006 — Tenancy dispute
Decided 23 Oct 2026 · Published 23 Oct 2026 · Application 5582006
At a glance
Key facts from the published tribunal order.
Adjudicator
H Ben Fayed
Claims & awards
What this tenancy cost at tribunal — claim, category, amount, and party awarded, with reconciled net total.
No individual claim amounts were reconciled for this order. View the official Ministry of Justice PDF for full detail.
Order
- The applicant and respondents name and details are suppressed.
- The application is dismissed.
Reasons
- Both parties attended the hearing.
- The applicant seeks to end the fixed-term tenancy early because the living habits of one or more of the other tenants at the property conflict with hers. She says this has led to what she alluded to as mental health strain and discomfort within the tenancy premises.
- The applicant also alluded to the fact that one of the tenants was male, whereas she had entered into the tenancy on the understanding that the property was for females. The respondent clarified that the proposed male tenant had been suggested by one of the existing tenants and that the applicant had expressly consented to him moving in. The applicant confirmed this. However, she says that she did not know him at the time and could not have known what would transpire. She provided few specifics about what had transpired, other than to say that he was a smoker and that he slept in and lived in darkness.
- Section 66 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1986 provides narrow criteria for ending a fixed-term tenancy early. There must be an unforeseen change in the applicant's circumstances, and the severe hardship that the applicant would suffer if the term of the tenancy were not reduced must be greater than the hardship that the other party to the tenancy would suffer if the term were reduced.
- The difficulties described by the applicant would no doubt be challenging to deal with. However, the difficulty for the applicant is that the respondent is amenable to ending the fixed-term tenancy and has communicated to her since August that she is willing for the tenancy to be ended early, provided the applicant bears the reasonable costs of re-tenanting the property.
- I have explained to the applicant that it is only if I determine that there has been an unforeseen change in her circumstances, resulting in severe hardship that outweighs the hardship to the respondent, that I would be able to terminate the tenancy under section 66. I do not consider that those criteria have been met.
- Living in close proximity to other people naturally gives rise to differences and, at times, conflict, which require communication, management and compromise, as do human relationships generally where people share living spaces.
- The difficulty in this case is that the applicant has unilaterally decided to leave the property. She has prevented the landlord from sharing her concerns with the other tenant, thereby inhibiting the landlord's ability to intervene or address those concerns. She has also prevented the landlord from disclosing that she has left the property, which has restricted the landlord's ability to advertise for a replacement tenant.
- I therefore find that the criteria under section 66 have not been met.
- Even if those criteria had been met, I have explained to the applicant that the reasonable costs associated with re-tenanting the property, together with rent payable until a replacement tenant is found, would likely have been taken into account in determining the terms of any order.
- The respondent's offer to end the tenancy early, subject to the applicant meeting the reasonable costs of re-tenanting, has been available since August and remains available. If the applicant wishes to limit her ongoing liability, it would be advisable for her to authorise the landlord to re-advertise the property and secure a replacement tenant.
- If any disagreement subsequently arises as to what constitutes reasonable re- tenanting costs, either party may bring a claim before the Tribunal for determination.
- At present, however, the applicant is actively impeding the landlord's ability to mitigate the parties' respective losses by imposing unreasonable restrictions on the re-tenanting of the property, which would otherwise enable this matter to be brought to a conclusion.
- Given the nature of the application, and the applicant having alluded to mental health difficulties and concerns for her safety, I have decided to exercise the Tribunal's discretion under section 95A(4) of the Act to suppress the identifying details of both parties and the address of the tenancy premises.
- The applicant has been unsuccessful in her application and must therefore bear her own filing fee.