Tenantcheck Insights · Case study
Tenancy Tribunal case 9081624 — Harassment in Henderson, Auckland
Decided 23 Oct 2026 · Published 23 Oct 2026 · Application 9081624
- Harassment
- Unit Titles
At a glance
Key facts from the published tribunal order.
Location
Auckland
Tribunal region
Adjudicator
M Pollak
Claims & awards
What this tenancy cost at tribunal — claim, category, amount, and party awarded, with reconciled net total.
No individual claim amounts were reconciled for this order. View the official Ministry of Justice PDF for full detail.
Order
- The Applicant’s claims are dismissed.
Reasons
- Both parties attended the hearing on 9 September 2026 at Waitakere District Court.
- The Respondents self-represented and the Applicant was represented by Clinton Baker and Conall Mac Fadyen from Price Baker Berridge , however it was clear to the Tribunal that a lot of work on the file had been carried out by Nauatea Crosswell as agent for the Applicant.
- The Applicant applied for declarations that the operational rules have been breached by the Respondents, recovery of costs in responding to those breaches and in bringing the claim to the Tribunal, reimbursement of the application fee and an order under s171(3A)(b) of the Unit Titles Act 2010 (UTA) requiring the Respondents to stop further actions towards other owners constituting the rule breaches. Background
- The current issues between the respondents and the applicant primarily began when the respondents sought consent to have a live in care and support person due to one of the respondent’s medical circumstances.
- The applicant did not consent to the respondents request to have a live in carer, which led to the care and support worker being evicted and the owner/occupiers having to have a family member move in to try and provide some of the care and support services required. This placed a significant strain on the family member and meant the male respondent was without the level of support he required to be safe in his own home when his wife was away at work.
- The former body corporate chairperson has complained of harassment and intimidation by the respondents and those complaints have led to breach notices being issued to the respondents and ultimately to these proceedings. Have the body corporate’s operational rules been breached by the respondents? Changing the applicant’s pleadings at the last minute on the morning of the hearing and notable errors in the documents and evidence filed
- In counsel for the applicant’s 15 May 2026 “Memorandum For Tenancy Tribunal Application” (“Memorandum”) claims the Respondents have breached the following Body Corporate operational rules (the Rules) and subsections of the Unit Titles Act 2010 (UTA): a. Rule 1(h) through confronting committee members on the complex and in their own home; b. Rule 1(l) through spreading misinformation to other owners about other owners and the Body Corporate Manager and sending abusive and lengthy emails; and c. Section 80(1)(j) by failing to comply with the Body Corporate Rules.
- The alleges the respondents have committed these breaches by: a. Spreading misinformation to other owners about other owners and the former body corporate manager; b. Confronting committee members on the complex, and in their homes; and c. Sending abusive and lengthy emails.
- At the start of the hearing, counsel for the applicant confirmed that it did not have sufficient evidence to prove the respondents engaged in the conduct set out in paragraph [8](a) and (c) above, these were no longer claims and that these incidents had been included in the amended application by way of background information only. Further, they confirmed they had sent a very last minute “Amended Submissions and Amended Claim for the Applicant for Hearing” after the close of business the evening prior. This document had not been processed by the registry before the hearing commenced that morning. In fact, I did not receive this electronic document until it was handed up during the hearing. As a result, I had no time to fully review this document, and the amended claims, prior to or during the hearing. I note that this “Amended Submissions and Amended Claim for the Applicant for Hearing” is for NZTT 9082304 and not the application before the Tribunal, which is application 9081624. This explains why it is likely the registry did not know where to file it in our case management system and demonstrates a complete lack of attention to these types of important litigation details, especially when you are filing submissions and amended claims on the morning of a half day morning hearing. I also note that the work in progress information (WIP) to support the applicant’s claim for costs was also full of errors. It then took until late on 10 September 2026 to file an amended cost claim and amended WIP, after confirming it could file those documents in the afternoon of 9 September 2026. I did not receive these amended documents until 11 September 2026 as a result.
- The amended bundle filed by counsel for the applicant, also on the morning of the hearing (as it was filed after 5pm the night before), also included allegations and a breach notice concerning Jennifer Hollier, who was not a respondent in these proceedings. At the hearing, the applicant acknowledged that this material had been included in error. I found it of interest that Ms Hollier had not had a Tribunal application made against her for what appears on the face of it very similar in nature to the conduct the applicant is complaining the respondents have engaged in.
- The respondents also advised me that in the 6:59pm email, sent the evening before the hearing, were advised the former chairperson’s sworn and signed affidavit would be presented at the hearing. This did not occur. The affidavit presented remained unsigned and unsworn. As such I can only give the contents of it limited weight, as I was also not provided with the opportunity to cross examine the former chairperson. Breach notice dated 19 December 2024
- The first breach notice submitted to the Tribunal in the applicant’s evidence was issued to the respondents on 19 December 2024. I note that the evidence suggests there may have been a prior breach notice issued by the committee prior to this breach notice, but if that notice exists it has not been provided to the Tribunal in evidence.
- This notice alleges that the respondents have engaged in conduct that breaches Section 79 of the UTA, “Rights of owners of principal units” which provides “an owner of a principal unit is entitled to have peace and enjoyment of his or her unit without interruption by other unit owners or occupiers, or the body corporate or its agents, except as authorised by this Act or the regulations”. The alleged breaches of this provision of the UTA are said to be as follows: a. On the evening of Sunday 1 December 2024, the female respondent allegedly called out “bitch” to Mrs Smith as she walked past the respondents’ home, with another committee member to the garden bags; b. On Tuesday 10 December 2024, the male respondent allegedly yelled out to Ms Smith from the back of his garage about covering her face, multiple times, when she was leaving her friend's home that day; c. In an email addressed to Ms Smith, dated 13 December 2024, the respondents mocked the fact that Ms Smith actively removes herself from any accusations by them by putting her arm up against her car's closed window when passing the respondents garage area, and that she has done so since the accusations began, which was after the breach notice issued by the committee; d. On Sunday 15 December 2024, at 11:05 am the respondents drove past the home of the Ms Smith while she was in her kitchen. She saw the female respondent drive the vehicle past her home with the window down and her arm deliberately raised up to "hide her face and afterwards turning around and driving back to their home. It is alleged that the male respondent had his passenger window down and was laughing as he repeated the same action as his wife.
- In support of this breach notice, the applicant has attached (note both are marked attachment F 19 December 2024 breach notice including CCTV photos): a. A screenshot of CCTV footage, that has no date or time stamp on it and no meta data to show when it was taken, that shows the respondents in their car and the mal respondent is resting his arm on the inside door frame. The face is not visible enough that I can see clearly who is in in the passenger seat. People often lean their arms on inside door frame like this for a variety of reasons. To conclude that the sole or dominant purpose of this action was to intimidate or harass Ms Smith is opinion based on very little objective fact or evidence and does not pin reality prove this action was harassment. This image could be the same as the jpg labelled Mike and Lisa_2024.12.15 (4) 11.10am.jpg. Without a time and date stamp I cannot be sure. b. A screenshot of CCTV footage, that is date and time stamped 15/12/24 at 11:09:37 Sun. This screen shot that shows the respondents car driving past Ms Smith’s unit. The driver is unclear to me in this image. The respondents say there is no other way to leave or enter the complex for them that allows them not to pass Ms Smith’s unit. Driving past Ms Smith’s home at this time of the day can hardly be considered evidence of harassment and intimidation and ascribes an intention the respondents vehemently deny.
- It is of note that there is no witness statement or affidavit from the committee member that allegedly witness the female respondent yelling the word “bitch” to Ms Smith when that committee member was accompanying Ms Smith to the garden bags on Sunday 1 December 2024. Had this been such an act of intimidation, I would have expected that this committee member would have recorded what he/she/it witnessed in writing to the committee or counsel for the applicant.
- It is also of note that the email addressed to Ms Smith, dated 13 December 2024, where the respondents mocked the fact that Ms Smith actively removes herself from any accusations by them by putting her arm up against her car's closed window when passing the respondents garage area, and that she has done so since the accusations began, is not attached to the breach notice or Ms Smith’s affidavit. In exhibit note “A” of Ms Smith’s affidavit, there are pictures of embedded pdf files called 2024.12.13 _gardening fees_Mike pdf, 2024.12.2_Additional harassment by Jenny, Mike and Lisa pdf, and 2024.12.10_more harassment from Mike Hunt_ Calling out.pdf. None of these pdf’s have been attached to the affidavit. There is also three jpgs embedded in the 15 December 2024 email from Ms Smith to the applicant’s lawyers, of which only one has obviously been provided as an attachment to the breach notice, and not Ms Smith’s affidavit.
- The respondents have vehemently refuted the applicant’s claims that they committed the breaches set out in the first breach and say that Ms Smith is being overly sensitive and reading intention into things that the respondents don’t have. They claim they have at no time set out to harass of intimidate her. They accept that were frustrated and disappointed at the stance that the applicant took to their request for a live in carer to be approved, when they consider this stance, and rule 4, to be in breach of New Zealand’s disability and human rights laws. Specifically, in response to the allegations set out in the 19 December 2024 breach notice, the respondents confirm: a. In relation to the 10 December 2024 allegation: the male respondent accepts that he may have called out once to enquire why the Chairperson was covering her face. He does not accept that he repeatedly yelled at her nor was he mocking her. He was simply seeking to understand why she was doing this when ever he came anywhere close to her. His wife confirmed that he has significant hearing loss and often speaks much louder than he realises. Speaking loudly because you are hearing impaired is not the same as trying to intimidate someone; b. In relation to the 10 December 2024 allegation: i. The respondents say their driving down the shared driveway within the complex has been deliberately miscategorised by Ms Smith to suit her intimidation and harassment narrative; ii. They drove down the driveway because a real estate agent was still with a potential buyer and they needed somewhere to turn around. They were engaged in their own conversation as they did so and did not see Ms Smith; iii. The female respondent’s arm was already raised as they travelled along the driveway. It was not something she did when they reached the Ms Smith’s property and it was not directed at Ms Smith. They were also laughing and talking between themselves at this time. The CCTV photographs in Attachment F simply show their vehicle passing and an arm raised. They do not show what was being said or why the female tenant has her arm in that position; iv. They did not stop, approach or threaten anybody and do not accept that driving on the shared driveway can in anyway be deemed to be harassment or intimidation; and v. The December 2024 breach notice also said that if there was any further harassment or intimidation, another separate breach notice would be issued. There have been no other formal conduct related breach notice being issued after this one. Warning letter dated 10 April 2025
- I note that the applicant’s 10 April 2025 letter (looks like a form of breach notice that is not labelled as such) to the respondents’ states: “We understand that you are engaging in aggressive behaviour in various forms towards the other owners and the Body Corporate Manager. The behaviour that has been described comprises: Spreading misinformation to other owners about other owners and the Body Corporate Manager. Confronting Committee members on the complex and in their homes. Sending abusive and lengthy emails. This behaviour is a breach of Rules 1(h) and 1(l) of the Body Corporate operational rules and s80(1)(d) of the Unit Titles Act 2010 (the Act). Please refrain from engaging in this kind of behaviour towards other owners and the Body Corporate Manager, including the enticement of other owners to act on your behalf in a similar manner. Failure to comply will likely result in the Body Corporate Committee instructing us to file a claim against you in the Tenancy Tribunal seeking an order under s171(3A)(b) of the Act.”
- There are no specific incidents, or details of the incidents, referred to in this letter to support the allegations made. There are no specific dates, times, places or people referred to in relation to these alleged breaches of the body corporate operational rules or s80(1)(d) of the UTA by the respondents. Instead, based on these generic and unsupported allegations the applicant makes a threat that failure to cease engaging in this generic conduct will “likely result in the Body Corporate Committee instructing us to file a claim against you in the Tenancy Tribunal seeking an order under s171(3A)(b) of the Act”. The letter then goes on to demand specific information too support the respondents request to be allowed to have a carer in their unit that the respondents have provided evidence to prove they had already provided when they made the original request. Further, the letter addresses the respondents request for the information they require to get a working remote control for the gate so that in medical emergencies the respondents can grant entry to emergency services. The respondents have also provided evidence that prior to this letter they had advised the applicant that Mr Minit could not programme a new remote without the requested information. This information appears to have been ignored by the applicant, for reason not disclosed.
- It would have been prudent for the applicant to have ensured that it had evidence of the rule breaches it alleged the respondents had engaged in, and to have included this evidence with a letter asking the respondents for their explanations to the clearly specified incidents that relate to each allegation, prior to getting their lawyers to send what is in form a breach notice.
- It would have also been prudent for the applicant to have provided evidence of all the respondents alleged breaches of the operational rules 1(h) and 1(l) to support its Tenancy Tribunal application. Instead, the applicant’s lawyers struggled to point the Tribunal to any compelling evidence that proves these alleged breaches.
- The “Amended Submissions and Amended Claim for the Applicant for Hearing” for NZTT 9082304 outlines some high level “confrontations” that purport to support the applicant’s application to the Tribunal for the orders it seeks.
- These alleged confrontations notably lack details like dates, times and exact locations the alleged confrontations occurred. They largely include hearsay, subjective opinion and supposition not supported by any objective evidence. Dianne Suzanne Smith is also said to have deposed that the scope of the confrontations extends to email correspondence that was not provided to the Tribunal in evidence. All the Tribunal received was an unsigned and unsworn will say document that I have no evidence Ms Smith wrote or confirms the contents to be true. She did not attend the hearing, so I was unable to question her on the contents of it. Given the high amount of typographical and other significant errors in counsel for the applicant’s documentation, I have concerns about whether this unsworn an unsupported affidavit may also contain such errors of fact or typographical errors that may change the meaning of the evidence it purports to give.
- The respondents deny all the applicant’s allegations. They remain concerned at the unfounded character assassination this Tribunal application levels at them and say they have not been given the opportunity to responded to at least one issue noted counsel for the applicant’s records of attendance, dated 8 May referring to “further issues of Mike shouting at people & threatening email”. The note does not say who the male respondent allegedly shouted at, when it happened, where it happened, what he said, and which emails were threatening or what the threat was and it has never been raised with the respondents. The only communication the respondents can identify that might possibly have been described that way concerned the entrance gate. Their gate remote had accidentally been run over and damaged, and they had been trying to arrange a replacement. The male tenant was worried because they did not have the control-box key or the information needed to get another remote coded. His concern was being able to get the gate open if emergency services needed access. He talked about disabling the gate if that became necessary to ensure access. He says this may have been taken as threatening but was him simply expressing that continued refusal to provide the code may result in that being a necessary action if emergency services could not enter the complex.
- The respondents accept the have at times sent lengthy emails, but these emails are not threatening or intimidating and do not deliberately and maliciously spread misinformation. They state the facts as the respondents reasonably believed the facts to be at that time. If they had spread misinformation, as is alleged, what exactly did they say that was false, to whom did they say it, when did they say it and how does Ms Smith know that what the respondents did say did not come from their reasonably held belief.
- For the reasons set out above, I find that the applicant has not provided sufficient evidence to prove its claims on the balance of probabilities that the respondents have breached operational rules1(h) and 1(l) and/or ss79(d) and 80(1)(i) of the UTA. I therefore dismiss the applicant’s claims for: a. A declaration the respondents have breached the body corporate rules arising from their alleged and unsubstantiated conduct towards other owners at the development; b. Orders under s171(3A)(b) of the UTA requiring the respondents to stop further action towards other owners in breach of the body corporate’s operational rules and their UTA based statutory owner/occupier obligations; c. Costs; and d. Reimbursement of the filing fee. Respondent’s costs
- The respondents have raised with the Tribunal that they intend to seek costs if the applicant is not wholly or substantially successful in its claims.
- They have provided the Smith & Partners Work in Progress Record, totalling $3,297.50, excluding GST. I understand that this WIP had not yet been billed as at the date of the hearing.
- The parties must try to agree the issue of the respondents’ costs between them. Where they are unable to reach agreement between themselves as to costs, the respondent party may make submissions to the Tribunal as to the basis of the costs it seeks. The applicant will be given 5 working days to respond to any such cost claim. Other miscellaneous claims
- The respondents seek compensation from the applicant for the significant personal time and effort they have spent responding to this application and the unpaid leave the female respondent has had to take off work. This has included time for reviewing extensive documentation, researching the matters raised, preparing evidence and submissions, preparing for and attending the hearing, responding to late amended material and responding to the applicant’s revised costs claim.
- The Tribunal is not aware of any provisions in the UTA or the UTA regulations that give it jurisdiction to award these types of costs, and the respondents have not directed the Tribunal to any such provisions that give it the jurisdiction to do so.
- This respondent cost claim is therefore dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
Topics & place
Topics are dispute themes across the order (not the same as claim-type money lines).
Residential Tenancies Act sections
s0800, s1, s10, s15, s171(3A), s27, s30, s79, s80(1)
Key findings
- Dispute theme: harassment
- Dispute theme: unit titles
Frequently asked questions
Common questions about this Tenancy Tribunal case.
What was Tenancy Tribunal case 9081624 about?
The tribunal order states: The Applicant’s claims are dismissed.
How much money was awarded in case 9081624?
Verified claim lines are listed on this page.
What type of tenancy dispute was case 9081624?
The primary dispute was Harassment. Related themes: Unit Titles.
Where can I read the official tribunal order for case 9081624?
The official Ministry of Justice published order is available at https://forms.justice.govt.nz/search/Documents/TTV2/PDF/14210661-UTA_Tribunal_Order.pdf.
For landlords & property managers
Reduce avoidable tribunal risk with proper tenant checks.
Tenantcheck reports take minutes: a small step before a dispute ends up at tribunal.